• Border City Wrestling
  • BCW Can-Am Heavyweight Championship (2 time)[15]
  • BCW Can-Am Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Nova[16]
• Busted Knuckle Pro Wrestling
  • BKPW Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Markus Ryan[17][18]
• Century Wrestling Alliance
  • CWA Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[11]
• Cutting Edge Wrestling
  • CEW North Atlantic Championship (1 time)[19]
• DDT Pro-Wrestling
  • Ironman Heavymetalweight Championship (2 times)[20]
• Eastern/Extreme Championship Wrestling
  • ECW World Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[9]
  • ECW World Tag Team Championship (3 times) – with Johnny Gunn (1), Raven (1) and Masato Tanaka (1)[21]
  • Hardcore Hall of Fame (2010)[13]
• Elite Pro Wrestling Alliance
  • EPWA Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[22]
• Family Wrestling Entertainment
  • FWE Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[23]
  • FWE Rumble (2013)[14]
• Impact Championship Wrestling
  • ICW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[24]
• International World Class Championship Wrestling
  • IWCCW Tag Team Championship (3 times) – with G.Q. Madison[10]
• International Wrestling Association
  • IWA Hardcore Championship (1 time)[25]
• International Wrestling Cartel
  • IWC Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[26]
• KYDA Pro Wrestling
  • KYDA Pro Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[27]
• Pro Wrestling Fighters
  • PWF North-European Championship (1 time)[28]
• Pro Wrestling Illustrated
  • Ranked No. 28 of the top 500 singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2000[29]
  • Ranked No. 184 of the top 500 greatest wrestlers in the "PWI Years" in 2003
• Pure Wrestling Association
  • Carrot Cup (2015) – with Rhino[30]
• Squared Circle Wrestling
  • 2CW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[31]
• Universal Championship Wrestling
  • UCW Universal Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[12]
• World Wrestling Federation / World Wrestling Entertainment
  • ECW Championship (1 time)[a][32]
  • WWF/E Hardcore Championship (14 times)[8]

a Dreamer's second ECW World Heavyweight Championship reign overall and first under the WWE banner.